This anonymous hero sent me a comment on that post and pointed me in the direction of TRUTH!!!
Learn more after the jump!
Heroic "Anonymous" sent me a link to this eBay listing for the E.T. board game.
With that, I began a rousing (actually sort of lazy) search for the E.T. board game on Google, and found a few great images belonging to other blogs:
This picture was found over at Brown That Banana! (Is that a reference I should be leery of?)
So... mystery solved! Thanks Anonymous! Now I wish I had one of those plastic blanket things!
I'll be back with more Goodwill Goodies soon enough! until then, Happy Hunting!